dua etmekteki inanılmaz mantık hatası

@1 dostum, cok guzel demissin ama 1500 yildir elestiriler ile evrilen bir dinin buna cevabinin olmamasini beklemiyorsun herhalde. eger duan gerceklesirse cevap vermis olacak, gerceklesmezse senin icin hayirlisi degilmis olacak.

ama katiliyorum sana. bak google tanri'ya sorunca ilk cikan linkte ne yaziyor:

prayer is a logical fallacy. by praying to god you are making 2 assumptions.

1) that he will defy the rules of physics to help specifically you.

2) that he will impose on free will

to refute the first claim there has been no evidence that the law of physics was just suspended and some kind of an anomaly happened. like for example, a guy who is about to get hit by a drunk driver just flies up into the air and lands in a safe spot.

to refute the 2nd claim. suppose you are getting robbed. you pray to god to make the robber go away. god does it. god just impended on the robber's free will to rob you. i thought he gave all humans free will?

thus, how can prayer follow the rules of logic?